Paperback: 240 pages
Publisher: Beacon Press; 1 edition (April 12, 2016)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0807074012
ISBN-13: 978-0807074015
Product Dimensions: 5.5 x 0.7 x 8.5 inches
Shipping Weight: 0.3 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 3.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (15 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #563,216 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #107 in Books > Biographies & Memoirs > Ethnic & National > Hispanic & Latino #381 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Specific Demographics > Hispanic American Studies #782 in Books > Politics & Social Sciences > Social Sciences > Emigration & Immigration
The USA definitely needs reasonable, respectful discussions on immigration reform, but this book does not provide them.I eagerly anticipated reading it, since immigration deserves serious dialogue (the World Economic Forum considers refugee flow the #1 global concern). By way of credentials, I’ve worked with overseas refugee/ immigrant communities and am a primary clinician at a health center with a new program dedicated to refugees. We care!This book is at one extreme of a spectrum. Here's its essence: "There’s no humane or ethical way to deny people who live in countries riddled with violence, poverty, and corruption the right to try to make a livable life in ‘your’ affluent country, much less so when ‘your’ country’s government has been deeply involved in creating the conditions being fled.” p.199 in my edition. This is a false dichotomy – supporting the humanity of those who seek to enter the US does not mean supporting an automatic entitlement to enter and stay at will. The argument also provides a false cause -- although the US government has given plenty of people (including citizens) varying degrees of a hard time up to and including death, to hubristically say this is the dominant cause of all the world’s vastly complex, multifactorial problems is to oversimplify far beyond usefulness, and will deeply obscure an ongoing search for a decent, reasonable solution.The book's main points are overcome by an intensely negative, shallow, emotional onslaught against the author’s adopted home. Indeed, it deserves two stars because it helps us understand an immigrant who despises the country they adopted (a valuable perspective, given recent events in Belgium).
As a legal immigrant myself (I moved here from Europe in the mid-80s), I am strongly in favor of an increase in legal migration. For one, we are terribly short on highly skilled labor. If you ask businesses in general what their toughest challenges are, hiring skilled employees is almost always at or near the top. I say all this because when I picked up this book, I admittedly knew not a whole lot about it, other than that it dealt with "migration and displacement".Once the book arrived and I started reading, I knew I was in trouble pretty quickly. The book is written by a Mexican who came to this country as a two year old with his "undocumented" parents but who eventually was able to move over to legal status and in fact is now a US citizen. Good for him! One might think that there would be some measure of gratitude and appreciation on the part of the author, but you might be wrong. On the contrary, the book can be viewed as a 240 page rant about illegal immigration. Indeed, the author feels "anger and resentment toward a punitive and racist government regarding its treatment of undocumented immigrants". Yes, you read right: the Obama administration is in the eyes of this author "punitive and racist". But wait! there is more! A good part of the book is devoted to his eventual obtaining US citizenship, which leads the author to reflect about the "absurdity" of getting a certificate for something he has "always" known: "I have a right to be here". Yes, you read right. The author states it as a matter of fact: all illegal immigrants have a "right" to be in the US. Never mind that of course US citizens don't have a right to be in Mexico or any other country without the proper visa or other paper work.
The Weight of Shadows: A Memoir of Immigration & Displacement Weight Watchers: 23 Healthy Snacks To Lose Weight Fast: (Weight Watchers Simple Start ,Weight Watchers for Beginners, Simple Start Recipes) (Weight ... Simple Diet Plan With No Calorie Counting) Weight Watchers Smoothies: 77 Weight Watchers Low Calorie Smoothie Recipes: (Weight Watchers Simple Start ,Weight Watchers for Beginners, Simple Start ... Simple Diet Plan With No Calorie Counting) Weight Watchers Diet Box Set: (3 in 1) Weight Watchers Freezer Meals, Weight Watchers Pressure Cooker & Weight Watchers Dutch Oven Recipes Hispanic Caribbean Literature of Migration: Narratives of Displacement (New Directions in Latino American Cultures) Juicing for Weight Loss: Unlock the Power of Juicing to Lose Massive Weight, Stimulate Healing, and Feel Amazing in Your Body (Juicing, Weight Loss, Alkaline Diet, Anti-Inflammatory Diet) (Volume 1) Facing the Shadows: A Christian Romance (The Shadows Trilogy Book 2) Two Best Sellers Book Bundle: Weight Loss, Addiction and Detox Series! (Enhanced Edition): 'Weight Loss by Quitting Sugar and Carb!' 'Dash Diet: Heart Health, High Blood Pressure, Cholesterol' Alkaline Juicing: Supercharge Your Body & Mind, Speed Up Massive Weight Loss (Naturally!), and Stimulate Holistic Healing (Alkaline Diet Lifestyle, Alkaline Diet for Weight Loss) (Volume 7) Juicing To Lose Weight: Fat Burning Juices & Weight Loss Blender Recipes Juice: Juicing Vegetables, Juicing Fruits, Juicing Alkaline, Juicing Raw & Juicing Paleo Weight Watchers One Pot Cookbook (Weight Watchers Cooking) Wheat Belly Diet For Beginners: Grain-Free, Wheat-Free, Gluten-Free Cookbooks and Recipes For Weight Loss Plans and Solutions Included! (Wheat Free Grain Free Gluten Free Weight Loss Diet) (Volume 1) Weight Loss by Quitting Sugar and Carb - Learn How to Overcome Sugar Addiction - A Sugar Buster Super Detox Diet (Weight Loss, Addiction and Detox) A Course in Weight Loss: 21 Spiritual Lessons for Surrendering Your Weight Forever Natural Rapid Weight Loss, Lose Weight Faster with Hypnosis, Meditation, and Affirmations: The Sleep Learning System Weight Loss Motivation Hacks: 7 Psychological Tricks That Keep You Motivated To Lose Weight The Calming Collection-The Weight is Over:Hypnosis/Meditation for Lasting Weight Loss**Guided Meditation and Hypnosis CD Weight Loss for People Who Feel Too Much: A 4-Step, 8-Week Plan to Finally Lose the Weight, Manage Emotional Eating, and Find Your Fabulous Self How Race Is Made in America: Immigration, Citizenship, and the Historical Power of Racial Scripts (American Crossroads) Coming to America: A History of Immigration and Ethnicity in American Life