Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 26 hours and 23 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: Tantor Audio
Audible.com Release Date: September 18, 2009
Whispersync for Voice: Ready
Language: English
ASIN: B002PXRRNI
Best Sellers Rank: #133 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Science Fiction > Adventure #672 in Books > Literature & Fiction > Action & Adventure > Science Fiction #1959 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Fiction & Literature
Writing a prequel to one of the greatest science fiction books ever written is no easy task. Herbert and Anderson are to be commended for even trying to craft this work, based at least partially on the notes left by Brian's illustrious father. Their success, however, is partial and this book is probably only of interest to Dune fanatics.The book concerns events that happened a generation before Dune. That's about as much as I can say about the plot because its principal fault is the lack of a narrative focus. We are treated to Pardot Kynes starting his lifelong study of Dune, to Shaddam IV scheming to get control of the Empire, to a villanous plot to take over the planet of Ix and to the rise of Leto Atreides. We even get information on the conception of Lady Jessica.Any one of these stories might have worked but the attempt to put all of them together makes the book slow (at 600+ pages, it is longer than most of the Dune books). A few threads should have been dropped.Additionally, the suspense of the book is watered down when you've read Dune. You know what the outcome of Leto's trial by forfeiture will be; you know how the Baron's breeding will work out. The really interesting stuff concerns Ix and House Vernius and I could have used a lot more of that and a lot less of Lady Jessica's conception.The book's appeal is not helped by the authors' style which is slow and repitive. They will tell you about the balance of power in the Empire at least a dozen times. This can be contrasted with Herbert the Elder's style, which was crisp and quick -- so much so that you really have to pay attention to know what was going on. This book is a lot more dumbed down.Hmmm. It sounds like I'm panning the book. I'm not. It's not *bad*, it's just not *great*.
Ok, sorry, but I had to change my review. Initially, I was about halfway into this book, and enjoying it well enough to give it a three star review. Now, I feel the need to change it, because I'm getting closer to finishing it and I know what really bothers me and why this book has so many 1-star reviews and arouses a general hatred in any seasoned Dune fans. Let me list the problems:1) The characters are 1-dimensional. Boring, flat, lacking personality. Herbert wrote from a 3rd person omniscient point of view, and this book is far from omniscient. You never get inside the characters' heads, you just read one dreary event after another.2) This book was written by two people. Every time I found myself enjoying it for a few pages, the writing style would change sharply and you could tell that the other author had taken over. I'm not quite sure who ruins this book, but I have a feeling it is Kevin J. Anderson, with some of the worst writing making me feel as though this is a Star Trek Novel.3) The dialogue is AWFUL. As one other reviewer stated, there are phrases and conversations in this book that would make Frank Herbert cringe, but to be more appropriate, he would roll over in his grave now.4) The lack of political/religious intrigue. There is no "magic" to this book, nothing that makes you put it down and let your imagination run wild. No messiah, no Muad'Dib (thank god they didn't even attempt to incorporate Paul Atreides since he wouldn't have even been born yet.), and hence no mystery, none of those moments you felt in awe of the original Dune world when Frank Herbert wrote it.5) The plot-spoilers of the original Dune series.
Dune: House Atreides: House Trilogy, Book 1 Heretics of Dune (Dune Chronicles) Dune: House Corrino: House Trilogy, Book 3 Navigators of Dune Draw 50 Cars, Trucks, and Motorcycles: The Step-by-Step Way to Draw Dragsters, Vintage Cars, Dune Buggies, Mini Choppers, and Many More... Dune Boy: The Early Years of a Naturalist Dune Dune Messiah Chapterhouse Dune Children of Dune God Emperor of Dune The Road to Dune Mile 81: Includes bonus story 'The Dune' Draw 50 Cars, Trucks, and Motorcycles: The Step-by-Step Way to Draw Dragsters, Vintage Cars, Dune Buggies, Mini Coopers Choppers, and Many More... Dune: The Machine Crusade Sandworms of Dune Tiny Houses: Tiny House Plans, Woodworking on a Tiny House and Living Mortgage Free (Tiny Houses, Tiny House Living, Tiny House Plans, Small Homes, Woodworking Book 1) House Harkonnen: House Trilogy, Book 2 Perelandra (Space-Cosmic-Ransom Trilogy, Book 2)(Library Edition) (Space Trilogy (Audio)) That Hideous Strength: A Modern Fairy-Tale for Grown-Ups (Space-Cosmic-Ransom Trilogy, Book 3)(Library Edition) (Space Trilogy (Audio))