Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 12 hours and 59 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: Audible Studios
Audible.com Release Date: September 19, 2012
Language: English
ASIN: B009D9LBYS
Best Sellers Rank: #111 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Religion & Spirituality > Judaism #2905 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Nonfiction > Social Science #4729 in Books > History > World > Jewish
Not having dug through the charges and counter-charges, I can't really comment on the disputes over how accurately the book recounts the details of the Rebbe's early life.I can say that the story is amazing to the extent it is true (and would be an amazing novel if it wasn't!) The basic outline is as follows: in the 1930s, Menachem Schneerson, despite his Hasidic ancestry and father-in-law, basically lived as a modern Orthodox Jew (although an extremely pious one, at least in some respects). He tried to become an engineer, but his ambitions were frustrated when France refused to allow him to practice (because he was not a French citizen) and Hitler's invasion of France forced him to flee to America (where his lack of English skills limited his opportunities). He then worked full-time for his father-in-law (the then-leader of the Chabad/Lubavitcher sect) because of some mix of personal piety, personal devotion to his father-in-law, and the lack of any career alternative.Schneerson was so brilliant and charismatic that Chabad Hasidim drafted him as rebbe of the sect himself a decade or so later, and over the ensuing decades he turned a tiny sect into a worldwide Jewish outreach organization. This is a story as astonishing as Moses' evolution from Egyptian prince to leader of Judaism- except it happened in our lifetimes!The book tries to explain why the Rebbe was so successful in leading Chabad. Some of the factors in his success were:*Because he had lived outside the bubble of a Hasidic neighborhood, he was somewhat able to relate to Jews outside that bubble.
This book has an interesting approach to research. Using the sources that will validate the authors theories and ignoring the information that challenges it. It seems they decided the outcome before they started the research and molded the book based on their prior assumptions.Their primary argument is that Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson was a student struggling with his identity in prewar Europe, pursuing his education as engineer. They paint a picture that he was disengaged from the Chassidic lifestyle dabbling in modern Western culture. In 1941 he escapes Nazi Europe and emerges as Jewish scholar and then becomes the Lubavitcher Rebbe, finding his true vocation.Historical research tells a far different story. The authors ignored the recent publications of multi volume work of Rabbinic Scholarship discovered posthumously by Rebbe from that period. They confuse it with the single volume Reshimos Hayoman, a diary of Chassidic lore from the same time. They have all kinds of claims about the Rebbe not attending synagogue and they ignore a wealth of testimony-much of it available on an oral history project by Jewish Educational Media, that tells are far different story. They also fail to examine the deep relationship between the Rabbi Schneerson and his father in law the previous Rebbe during the thirties. Either the authors research was so superficial that they could not find the material that is sold in many Jewish bookstores and online, or they choose to ignore historical sources that refute their primary assumption. As so called scholars, at the minimum they should have presented this material and then their arguments refuting it. They choose to act like it does not exist.
The Rebbe: The Life and Afterlife of Menachem Mendel Schneerson Turning Judaism Outwards: A Biography of the Rebbe Menachem Mendel Schneerson Rebbe: The Life and Teachings of Menachem M. Schneerson, the Most Influential Rabbi in Modern History The Torah Discourses of the Holy Tzaddik Reb Menachem Mendel of Rimanov 1745-1815 Gregor Mendel: The Friar Who Grew Peas Bringing Heaven Down to Earth: 365 Meditations of the Rebbe Chumash: The Gutnick Edition - Book of Exodus - Kol Menachem (Full Size) Chumash: The Gutnick Edition - Book of Leviticus - Kol Menachem (Full Size) Unbelievable: The Life, Death, and Afterlife of the Notorious B.I.G. Spirals in Time: The Secret Life and Curious Afterlife of Seashells Life on the Other Side:: A Psychic's Tour of the Afterlife Anne Frank: The Book, The Life, The Afterlife After One-Hundred-and-Twenty: Reflecting on Death, Mourning, and the Afterlife in the Jewish Tradition (Library of Jewish Ideas) Dying to Wake Up: A Doctor's Voyage into the Afterlife and the Wisdom He Brought Back After Death Signs from Pet Afterlife & Animals in Heaven: How to Ask for Signs & Visits and What it Means Animals and the Afterlife: True Stories of Our Best Friends' Journey Beyond Death Jesus - The Missing Years, New Teachings, and the Afterlife: Based On The Urantia Book Proof of Heaven: A Neurosurgeon's Near-Death Experience and Journey into the Afterlife Dirk Quigby's Guide to the Afterlife: All You Need to Know to Choose the Right Heaven, Plus a Five-Star Rating System for Music, Food, Drink, & Accommodations Anubis Speaks!: A Guide to the Afterlife by the Egyptian God of the Dead (Secrets of the Ancient Gods)