Paperback: 440 pages
Publisher: Broadway Books; Reprint edition (March 27, 2012)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0307461734
ISBN-13: 978-0307461735
Product Dimensions: 5.2 x 0.9 x 8 inches
Shipping Weight: 10.6 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.5 out of 5 stars See all reviews (139 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #440,354 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #39 in Books > History > Americas > Canada > Province & Local #63 in Books > Biographies & Memoirs > Historical > Canadian #78 in Books > Biographies & Memoirs > Regional Canada
I've never written a book review before, so excuse me if I'm not on par with the other reviewers. I'm a modern guy and I like TV more than anything, so my measure of a book is how engrossing it is and how much it manages to pry me away from the television. "The Floor of Heaven" is pretty damn good. The back of the book compares it to "a horseless-carriage episode of 24." I've never watched 24, but I can definitely see them squeezing one or two seasons out of this book for television.What's hard is trying to criticize this book. It's based on a true story. So, I'm looking at how it's presented, and if it's a story worth listening to. The answer to both is, "Yes." First we're introduced to the three main characters a Cowboy, a Conman, and a Dreamer, and they are very interesting individuals. Once I was invested, I couldn't wait for all three to crash into each other in Alaska. There are a handful of really great tales inside, but the main story is the "Great Gold Robbery" in the middle of the book. That part is what peeled me away from the TV for the longest time. It's pretty ingenious how the thieves stole the gold, and tracking down the perpetrators has the detectives tossed around Alaska and in some tights spots."Is this book going to turn into Treasure of the Sierra Madre?" I thought it would, but no it doesn't. Greed plays only a tiny part.I was going to give this book 4-Stars. I thought I'd learn about all the different techniques prospectors used for mining gold or how they survived in the wilderness. There wasn't much new to learn. I'm giving it 5-Stars, because Charlie Siringo is my new hero. He's not Batman, he's just a cowboy/detective with his wits, and he favors caution over resorting to violence.
I am, like a previous reviewer, a tour guide and naturalist in Alaska and the Yukon. Let's get straight to the point: this book is lying when it claims to be "A True Tale Of The Last Frontier And The Yukon Gold Rush". The author clearly made up events. Just as offensive to us who love this northern region, the author didn't even bother to learn some basics about the area's geography and ecology...and so he gets some things very wrong. Observe:p. 106 "Dark herd of walruses pounded through the water like a freight train. And beyond the horizon...was the gold town of Juneau, Alaska". Walruses do not live anywhere near Juneau and the Inside Passage; they live far away on the western Alaska coasts of the Bering Sea and Chukchi Sea. The author should have spent 10 seconds looking at a walrus range map, easily Googled.p. 216 Describing a whale hunt: ""Sighting carefully, he took a bead on a broad spot right behind where he imagined the gills might be." Whales don't even have gills. Fish have gills, and whales are not fish - they are mammals.p. 217 After sailing into an inlet, "A swift inland river pulled them along to the banks of an Indian village." A swift river never pulls the boat along when you go upstream from salt water; just the opposite - the downstream current fights you and tries to push you back out to the coast.p. 257 The author states that the Klondike (aka Throndiuk) River is 50 miles north of the settlement of Fortymile. Wrong - it is near Dawson City, way SOUTH of the old Fortymile village. Look at any map; the Klondike River enters the Yukon River near Dawson City.p. 286 Describing George Carmacks out prospecting: "As before, George was pulled toward Eldorado Creek.
Howard Blum is candid about his intent with the writing of The Floor of Heaven. In his note on sources he says he wanted to write a true story about the early days of the old west and of the far north. "True" is a key word here because stories of that period are notoriously embellished by participants and observers. Finding the truth in the accounts of the time is a treacherous journey. Blum knows this and realized from the outset that he would have to proceed cautiously. I believe he has assembled his material, carefully vetted it, and written his story as he intended it to be. It is fine investigative reporting.The Floor of Heaven is subtitled as a true tale of the American West and the Yukon gold rush. It's an intriguing story of three men very different in mind-set and integrity who eventually are drawn together by their individual aspirations. It's a story of a hard-working miner who strikes it big and needs the protection of a dedicated detective from a ruthless robber and con-man. Blum puts it all together in a masterful, exciting book.I got a true sense of the time frame. Even the font at the beginning of each chapter made me think "old west." The individuals were carefully crafted as genuine pioneer characters and the dialogue was authentic and believable. The events were familiar milestones in American history. It all came off believable, but I had a problem with the overall feel of the book.The author didn't draw me into the grit and turmoil of the old west and early Alaska. When I read Jack London my hands and feet become icy, I feel cold snow on my neck, and I smell a wood fire and frying bacon. I see spreads of impenetrable forest, heavy snow, and frigid mountain peaks.
The Floor of Heaven: A True Tale of the Last Frontier and the Yukon Gold Rush The Floor of Heaven: A True Tale of the American West and the Yukon Gold Rush (Thorndike Press Large Print Popular and Narrative Nonfiction Series) Yukon Gold: The Story of the Klondike Gold Rush Good Time Girls of the Alaska-Yukon Gold Rush: Secret History of the Far North I Witness: Hard Gold: The Colorado Gold Rush of 1859: A Tale of the Old West (I Witness Novels) A Frontier Lady: Recollections of the Gold Rush and Early California Hard Gold: The Colorado Gold Rush of 1859 (I Witness Novels) Stack Silver, Buy Gold, For Beginners: How And Why To Invest In Physical Precious Metals And, Protect Your Wealth, When The, Money Bubble Pops (Silver, ... Silver, Gold Fever, Gold Wars, FED Book 1) Coldplay - A Rush of Blood to the Head (Rush of Blood to the Head Pvg) Romance: INSPIRATIONAL FRONTIER ROMANCE: A Place to Call Home (Pioneer Christian Romance Novelette) (Inspirational Western Frontier Romance) To Heaven and Back: A Doctor's Extraordinary Account of Her Death, Heaven, Angels, and Life Again: A True Story Nothing Too Good for a Cowboy: A True Account of Life on the Last Great Cattle Frontier Heaven is Beyond Your Wildest Expectations: Ten True Stories of Experiencing Heaven The Last Voyage of Columbus: Being the Epic Tale of the Great Captain's Fourth Expedition, Including Accounts of Swordfight, Mutiny, Shipwreck, Gold, War, Hurricane, and Discovery Hard Road West: History and Geology along the Gold Rush Trail The California Gold Rush: An Interactive History Adventure (You Choose Books) (You Choose: History) The Gold Rush (Life in the Old West) Gold Rush Fever: A Story of the Klondike 1898 The Klondike Gold Rush (First Books--Western U.S. History) Sterling Point Books®: Stampede for Gold: The Story of the Klondike Rush