File Size: 2421 KB
Print Length: 220 pages
Publisher: Gallup Press (September 16, 2013)
Publication Date: September 16, 2013
Sold by: Simon and Schuster Digital Sales Inc
Language: English
ASIN: B005Q14N7E
Text-to-Speech: Not enabled
X-Ray: Not Enabled
Word Wise: Enabled
Lending: Not Enabled
Enhanced Typesetting: Enabled
Best Sellers Rank: #257,541 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store) #16 in Books > Business & Money > Economics > Unemployment #53 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Business & Money > Biography & History > Labor Policy #93 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Business & Money > Economics > Labor & Industrial Relations
I bought this book after a friend who is a voracious reader mentioned it was what she was currently reading and seeing the many five star reviews. I had reasonable expectations despite the fact I am leery of any conversation that frames itself using the word "War". Unfortunately for me this book did not live up to its five star rating or my expectations.The "Coming Jobs War" essentially is a plan to avert societal collapse. While I agree with many of the prescriptions that Jim Clifton brings forth throughout the book, the book is just that- prescriptive in both tone and content. The book is written in the style of a bad self-help book or perhaps like the legion of "how to win in business" type books. As in such books "The Coming Jobs War" makes a sweeping generalization which is then supported by vague statements using pseudo-scientific mumbo-jumbo.While elements of the plan to avert societal collapse make sense, and many I agree with, they are presented in a linear, deterministic manner which completely miss the complex, systemic approaches that will be needed to address the issues the book seeks to contribute its voice to solving. Even worse, this book fails to provide much data to back up its claims or meaningfully acknowledge other thinkers and theories that supportable or refute the claims being made. While there is an extensive list of references at the end, they exist independent of the rest of the book (at least in the Kindle edition I read)."The Coming Jobs War" suffers in other ways that alienated me as a reader from the important (and likely valid) points raised:- Entrepreneurs are given mythic, superhero status. The impact, societal benefit, or long term sustainability of the entrepreneur's idea is irrelevant.
I read many online reviews before downloading this book. Both sides of the political spectrum seemed to hate it, arguing that it is over simplistic and just plain wrong-headed or biased. Frankly, that's exactly why I found myself curled up non-stop reading the entire book in one sitting. It is NOT politically correct, sure. But Clifton's observations merit serious consideration. To anger the right wing, he argues that with GDP driving jobs, and with "good" jobs driving the economy, significant cuts in the federal budget will be counterproductive, both in the short and longer term. A smaller government cuts off vital support to the many services and supports that a growing economy needs (pre-K through higher education, basic scientific research, safe streets, etc.). To aggravate the left wing, he makes a good case that "taxing the rich" simply cannot generate enough revenue to even come close to making up for fiscal shortfalls, so entitlement programs must inevitably be dialed down. Then, his take on healthcare will offend just about anyone who is not at an ideal body weight, doesn't exercise, eschews preventive medical exams, and wants to claw out every last day of life in an expensive terminal illness. Well, as a medical industry executive for the past 30 years, my first reaction was to challenge his claim that healthcare costs are nothing but a drag on jobs growth (after all, what's wrong with an industry that employs 1/5 of all American workers . . . many in what he defines as "good" jobs . . . in every single town and city in the country, improves health, and for the most part cannot be outsourced to China). Yet, in the end, I'm forced to agree with his points, even on healthcare.
Jobs Rated Almanac: The Best and Worst Jobs - 250 in All - Ranked by More Than a Dozen Vital Factors Including Salary, Stress, Benefits, and More (Jobs Rated Almanac, 6th Ed, 2002) Coming Jobs War The Coming Jobs War Pharaohs and Foot Soldiers: One Hundred Ancient Egyptian Jobs You Might Have Desired or Dreaded (Jobs in History) Archers, Alchemists: and 98 Other Medieval Jobs You Might Have Loved or Loathed (Jobs in History) Jobs for English Majors & Other (3rd ed) (Jobs for English Majors and Other Smart People) Great Jobs for Chemistry Majors, Second ed. (Great Jobs For... Series) Horrible Jobs of the Renaissance (History's Most Horrible Jobs) Pasta (Company's Coming) (Company's Coming) Jewish Americans (Coming to America) (Coming to America (Barron's Educational)) Behold a White Horse: The Coming World Leader: The Coming World Leader Aliens Are Coming!: The True Account Of The 1938 War Of The Worlds Radio Broadcast ISIS, Iran and Israel: What You Need to Know about the Current Mideast Crisis and the Coming Mideast War Dreadnought: Britain, Germany, and the Coming of the Great War Blood on the Altar: The Coming War Between Christian vs. Christian Sons of Privilege: The Charleston Light Dragoons in the Civil War (Civil War Sesquicentennial Edition) (Civil War Sesquicentennial Edition (University of South Carolina Press)) Korean Vignettes: Faces of War : 201 Veterans of the Korean War Recall That Forgotten War Their Experiences and Thoughts and Wartime Photographs of That Era Street Farm: Growing Food, Jobs, and Hope on the Urban Frontier Dinosaurs with Jobs: A Coloring Book Celebrating Our Old-School Coworkers Clothesline Clues to Jobs People Do