Paperback: 384 pages
Publisher: Vintage; Paperback Edition edition (December 5, 2006)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1400095794
ISBN-13: 978-1400095797
Product Dimensions: 5.2 x 0.8 x 8 inches
Shipping Weight: 12.6 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 3.8 out of 5 stars See all reviews (23 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #318,749 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #7 in Books > Arts & Photography > Performing Arts > Dance > Tango #10 in Books > Arts & Photography > Performing Arts > Dance > Popular #1413 in Books > Arts & Photography > History & Criticism > Criticism
Although Thompson's book has a veneer of academic research, it is merely an attempt to promote the position advocated in his other books: Thompson alleges that much, if not most, of the elements of culture for which (mostly European) white societies are credited was "stolen" (that is, copied without credit) from black (in most cases, African) societies.In "Tango", Thompson, a professor of African art (he has no qualifications either in dance or in Latin American culture) makes two arguments: a general, deductive one and a specific, inductive one.His deductive argument is essentially "white men can't jump". That is, he reasons from effect and concludes that tango must have been stolen from blacks because it is improvised, and everyone knows that white people can't improvise. White people must have structure. That's why, Thompson says, just as classical music is "white" music and jazz is "black" music, ballroom and ballet are "white" dances, and tango is a "black" dance.Thompson's inductive argument is based, in large part, on a list of people he has compiled, and who he claims are variously the world's greatest tango dancers, singers, composers and musicians. All of the people on Thompson's list are black. Thus, he alleges, he has "proved" that tango was co-opted from blacks.Assuming that Thompson's list of the "greatest" has some validity, that would not prove that white people stole the tango from the individuals he selected, much less from any other blacks who didn't make his list.If Thompson's argument were correct, that would also mean that golf was stolen by the Scottish from African-Americans, because Tiger Woods is black. (I suppose that's his next book.
First Tango in Paris September 2016: How to Dance Tango (First Tango in Cities Around the World) Why Tango: Essays on learning, dancing and living tango argentino (Tango Essays Book 1) Tango: Argentine tango music, dance and history A Passion for Tango: A Thoughtful, Provocative and Useful Guide to That Universal Body Langauge, Argentine Tango Argentine Tango: Wisdom of Great Followers (Learning Argentine tango) (Volume 3) Learn Authentic Tango: Mystery Revealed (In Color) (Learning Argentine Tango) (Volume 4) Why Tango: Essays on learning, dancing and living tango argentino (Volume 1) Beginning Argentine Tango: To the people who are interested in dancing Argentine Tango--This is how to do it Tango for Teachers: The tango matrix Arreglos de Tango Para Piano En Autentico Estilo Argentino: An Essential Guide to the Correct Playing of the Argentine Tango Including 10 Transcriptio Dead on Her Feet: A Tango Mystery (An Antonia Blakeley Tango Mystery) (Volume 1) Tango.: Dance Of Leaders (How to dance Argentine Tango) (Volume 1) Tango.: Dance of Great Leaders (Learning Arg. Tango) (Volume 2) Tango: Wisdom of Following (Learning Argentine Tango) (Volume 2) More Than Two to Tango: Argentine Tango Immigrants in New York City Tango Argentino: How to Tango: Steps, Style, Spirit (Dance Crazy) Tango: The Art History of Love Aloha: Love, Suite Love/Fixed by Love/Game of Love/It All Adds Up to Love (Inspirational Romance Collection) Love's Unending Legacy/Love's Unfolding Dream/Love Takes Wing/Love Finds a Home (Love Comes Softly Series 5-8) Art: Painting For Artists - Styles: Acrylic And Oil Painting (art history, art books, art theory, art techniques Book 2)