Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 8 hours and 13 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: Audible Studios
Audible.com Release Date: November 17, 2009
Whispersync for Voice: Ready
Language: English
ASIN: B002XGLCVA
Best Sellers Rank: #44 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Science > Mathematics #249 in Books > Science & Math > Mathematics > History #295 in Books > Science & Math > Mathematics > Geometry & Topology
Mlodinow ('M' below) writes entertainingly, as most of the other reviews here testify. It's good that the general public get a taste of the excitement of discovery/invention in these fields. He should just correct, in a subsequent edition, the serious distortions that IAS Professor Langlands (Notices of the American Mathematical Society, vol. 49, number 5, p. 554 - referred to as 'L' below) has pointed out; then the book could be a useful, reliable introduction to whet the appetite of people who might want to study the subjects in more depth. Here are a few of Langlands' criticisms:1. M's portrayals of Proclus, Kant, Kronecker and Gauss' father are unfair caricatures. L provides evidence in their defense.2. M strives for sensationalism, not fact. E.g., M speculates that Thales traded in leather dildos. Veracity is sacrificed to effect.3. M missed the main point of Riemann's great 1854 habilitation lecture. L wrote: "I could hardly believe my eyes, but it seems [M] is persuaded that the introduction of elliptic geometry was the principal achievement of the lecture."Since M acknowledges on p.205 that Einstein's general theory of relativity was based on Riemann's work, M owes the reader much more explanation of Riemann's new ideas, expanding on his p. 207 discussion, not dismissing Riemann by saying his work "wasn't pretty."4. L criticizes M's account of Einstein's early years, saying: "...to represent Einstein as an academically narrow, misunderstood or mistreated high-school dropout is a cruel disservice to any young reader or to any educator who swallows such falsehoods."5. L concludes that M's book is "thoroughly dishonest ... simply because the author shrinks from nothing in his desperation to be readable and entertaining.
As a teacher of geometry, I always keep an eye out for books that offer coherent explanations of the importance of this most intriguing and ancient branch of mathematics. This books offers that in spades. In fact, it is one of the best basic overviews of the field I have ever come across.Mlodinow divides the history of the development of geometry into five major "revolutions." Starting first with Euclid and his Greek contemporaries, Mlodinow traces the field through Descartes and the development of analytic geometry, Gauss and the development of "non-Euclidean" geometries, Einstein and the physical application of these geometries, to Witten and the development of string theory--the attempt to understand the universe as a consequence of geometry. In high school we teach the basics of plane and analytic geometry but few people are aware of how the field has matured since then. This book takes us on that journey.And it is a wonderful one. Along the way he gives insight not only into the mathematics but also into the personalities that created it. We too often forget that it is people who created this magnificent structure and that it was not just handed down to us perfectly formed. Even more, we need to be reminded that the development continues and people are still contributing to it.The real achievement of this book, however, is its acessiblity. Despite the fact that most people will only have experience with the material from the first two sections of the book (Euclid and Descartes), Mlodinow's writing is understandable by anyone who has successfully navigated a course in high school geometry. In my view, he offers one of the most lucid explanations of Einstein's work and string theory that I have ever read. His style is engaging and very readable.
This is by and large the worst popular science book I've ever come across (and being an astronomer and translator of popular science, I've read quite a number of them). Mlodinow violates almost all rules of scientific method and conduct, and even some of rules governing the plain civility in writing. There are literally hundreds of examples of such violations, so let me mention just a few of them. Mlodinow engages in hero-worship to an unprecedented degree: he does not shy away from pronouncing Witten "the most influential physicist and mathematician in the world" (p.253), as if such a grandeloquent statement can ever be proven or even properly supported. He enjoys judging long-dead people without proper history knowledge: he finds Cantor genius and Kronecker "a crab", he outrageously states that medieval Arabs didn't contribute anything original to mathematics (perhaps he should have taken some *history* courses from Witten, who knows better for certain!) and then, a dozen or so pages later, contradicts himself by citing some important results of two Arab mathematicians; he finds geometry and calculus more cognitively important than algebra (a dubious statement and quite improper for a popular work); he censores ancient Romans for their decadent ways (while simultaneously celebrating Athenian often quite promiscuous "symposia"); he does not know that Sirius is the brightest star which can be seen from Greece; he calls Aristotle just a meteorologist (p. 56). In addition, Mlodinow heavily indulges in what serious historians call "Whiggish interpretation of history", i.e. judging of the past by its present utility.
Euclid's Window: The Story of Geometry from Parallel Lines to Hyperspace The Stark Hyperspace War (Star Wars) Parallel Scientific Computing in C++ and MPI: A Seamless Approach to Parallel Algorithms and their Implementation Parallel Programming: Techniques and Applications Using Networked Workstations and Parallel Computers (2nd Edition) Parallel Programming with Intel Parallel Studio XE Introduction to Parallel Computing: Design and Analysis of Parallel Algorithms Short Stories in Spanish: New Penguin Parallel Text (New Penguin Parallel Texts) (Spanish and English Edition) Learn German: Parallel Text - Easy, Funny Stories (German - English) - Bilingual (Learning German with Parallel Text Book 1) Learn German III: Parallel Text - Easy Stories (German - English) Bilingual - Dual Language (Learning German with Parallel Text 3) (German Edition) The King of Infinite Space: Euclid and His Elements Showplace of America: Cleveland's Euclid Avenue, 1850-1910 (Ohio) Geometry: Integration, Applications, Connections Student Edition (MERRILL GEOMETRY) Janice VanCleave's Geometry for Every Kid: Easy Activities that Make Learning Geometry Fun (Science for Every Kid Series) Janice VanCleave's Geometry for Every Kid: Easy Activities that Make Learning Geometry Fun Photogrammetric Computer Vision: Statistics, Geometry, Orientation and Reconstruction (Geometry and Computing) Constructing Walking Jazz Bass Lines, Book 1: Walking Bass Lines- The Blues in 12 Keys Upright Bass and Electric Bass Method Ron Carter: Building Jazz Bass Lines: A compendium of techniques for great jazz bass lines including play-along CD featuring Ron Carter (Bass Builders) Adsl/Vdsl Principles: A Practical and Precise Study of Asymmetric Digital Subscriber Lines and Very High Speed Digital Subscriber Lines (Macmillan Technology Series) Between the Lines (Between the Lines #1) 250 Ultimate Funny Pick Up Lines: Hilarious, Cute, and Cheesy Pick Up Lines to Meet Women